
Practical guide · Educational reading
How to distinguish physical-content evidence, mass-balance attribution and book-and-claim instruments before approving a sustainability claim.
Audience / jurisdiction: International; procurement, sustainability, supply-chain, marketing and internal-audit teams
Start with what the claim means
When a supplier presents a sustainability claim, the first question is not simply whether it mentions an ISO standard. It is what the evidence actually demonstrates: the physical content of a product, an allocation made through mass-balance accounting, or a characteristic transferred separately through a book-and-claim system.
ISO’s 20 March 2026 announcement introduces ISO 22095-2:2026 for mass balance and ISO 22095-3:2026 for book and claim. This guide uses that announcement as background, rather than as current news. It is intended for procurement, sustainability, supply-chain, marketing and internal-audit teams reviewing claims across international supply chains.
Sources: [1]
Understand the model before accepting the evidence
ISO explains mass balance as an approach that permits materials to be mixed while quantities and attributed characteristics are tracked. The practical distinction is between accounting for an eligible input and demonstrating that a particular delivered item physically contains that input.
Book and claim separates the administrative transfer of specified characteristics from the physical movement of materials. Instruments are created, transferred and retired to support claims and reduce the risk of counting the same entitlement more than once.
As a hypothetical example, a purchasing team could receive evidence of an allocated characteristic without receiving proof of that characteristic’s physical presence in each purchased item. Its approval process should preserve that distinction instead of treating all chain-of-custody models as interchangeable.
Sources: [1]
Separate traceability from substantiation
The ISO 22095:2020 catalogue makes an important limitation explicit: the framework alone cannot substantiate a material or product claim. A chain-of-custody system does not, by itself, establish the claimed characteristic or the conditions under which something was produced.
Reviewers should therefore separate two questions. First, what evidence establishes the underlying characteristic? Second, what evidence connects that characteristic to the organization’s proposed claim? A standard reference is not a substitute for answering either question.
This also helps distinguish the role of an international standard from acceptance under a particular customer contract, certification scheme or legal regime. Those criteria need their own review.
Sources: [2]
Build a claim-specific evidence trail
AdviseISO recommends starting with a written claim record: the characteristic being claimed, quantity, product or activity, reporting period and intended audience. Then identify whether the evidence concerns physical segregation, mass-balance attribution or separately transferred instruments.
For mass balance, request a worked trail connecting input and output records, accounting boundaries, conversion assumptions and reconciliation. For book and claim, request instrument identifiers, ownership history and evidence of retirement. Ask the evidence owner to explain how the trail supports the specific wording proposed.
Next, examine duplication risk. Could the same quantity or entitlement appear in another transaction, customer claim or reporting period? Record how this has been checked and resolve unexplained overlaps before approval. These are editorial review suggestions, not a complete statement of ISO requirements.
Sources: [1]
Approve the wording, not just the paperwork
Before release, compare each significant phrase in the claim with its supporting evidence. Avoid wording that implies physical product content when the records support only attribution or a separate entitlement. Keep the approved wording and supporting records together so later reviewers can reconstruct the decision.
The March announcement date is not a legal effective date or certification-transition deadline. The consulted sources establish no general mandatory implementation deadline. Detailed conformity decisions require the applicable full standards and relevant scheme criteria; the immediate practical step is to select one existing claim and test whether its evidence and wording align.
Sources
- ISO — New ISO standards bring clarity to chain of custody
- ISO 22095:2020 — Chain of custody — General terminology and models
Your experience
For one sustainability claim your organization currently uses, can you demonstrate whether the evidence supports physical product content, mass-balance attribution or a separately retired entitlement?